Skip navigationAlternative Medicine: All in Your Mind?
 

1. Story map

2. Quacky cough medicine?

3. Place for placebo effect?

4. Hip, hyp, hypnotize

5. Worried about St. John's wort

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Hidden injections given through IV lines are less effective than "open" (obvious) injections. Image shows old-style intravenous apparatus.

  I think, therefore I cure
round, orange pill with the word 'sugar' stamped on itFor many years, the placebo effect was a researcher's nightmare. Just because people took part in research, they get better. Not all of them, but enough to bollix up the statistics.

A similar phenomenon occurs in the doctor's office, researchers believe. "The placebo effect is a context effect," explains Fabrizio Benedetti, a neuroscientist at the University of Turin, who investigates how the placebo effect influences pain. "Words, touch, smell, sight are the context of medicine."

Context determines expectations, and expectations are the root of the placebo effect.

Now, after years of trying to sidestep placebo, researchers have figured something out: If mindset and expectation can influence health, isn't that something we should know about?

Close-up of needle injecting into skin. Because the placebo effect could explain why such alternative approaches as energy healing or prayer can work -- without a doctor touching a patient or giving a single drug -- the research is part of the new interest in studying complementary and alternative medicine.

Said it ain't so...
The placebo effect has never been popular among medical doctors, who have made it less welcome than a hungry pack of coyotes at a shepherd's convention. Skeptics got a new argument in May 2001, when Danish researchers published -- and the media trumpeted -- a debunking of the effect in the New England Journal of Medicine. After looking at 114 previous studies, Peter Gotzsche and Asbjorn Hrobjartsson concluded that, aside from pain, the placebo effect was -- nothing.

Nadasville.

In covering the study, the New York Times scoffed that placebo was "more myth than science."

Graph shows that pain is reduced when patients are given open, rather than hidden, injections of painkiller.Painkillers work much better when patients know they are getting them. Data for Metamizal from "Response Variability ..." in the bibliography).

But critics noted that Linde had lumped research on several ailments, perhaps masking the effectiveness of particular placebo treatments on particular diseases. At any rate, one study failed to derail the growing interest in how the mind can heal the body.

As evidence for the placebo effect continues to mount, it increasingly takes the form of hard data. To the average physician, PET and MRI scans maybe tougher to ignore than patient testimony.

Placebo pain (studies)
In pain research, Benedetti and colleagues have compared hidden and open administration of painkillers in 278 post-operative patients in two conditions:

Open vs. hidden administration: To study placebo's psychological roots, patients got the painkiller either via injection ("open") or an existing intravenous line ("hidden")

Mechanism of pain relief: To test how whether the placebo effect was due to opioids (pain-killing chemicals) produced in the body, some patients received an antagonist -- an agent that blocks opiates from working.

The results (see "Response Variability ..." in the bibliography) were clear: Open administration makes painkiller work better. The difference, Benedetti says, is the placebo effect. And because opiate antagonists reduce the placebo effect, it seems that the placebo effect occurs when the brain -- expecting pain relief -- causes the body to produce endogenous opioids -- natural painkillers.

Translated, if you expect to get painkillers, your body may produce them for you. Still, no matter how great the placebo effect may be, it relies on deception. That may be legitimate for research studies, but not in the real world.

Says Straus: "You can't deceive the patient in clinical medicine." So before anybody puts this valuable thing into practice, there are ethical hurdles to jump.

Still, you can hypnotize patients...

 

 

 
BackMore
       
  The Why Files   There are 1 2 3 4 5 pages in this feature.
Bibliography | Credits | Feedback | Search

©2002, University of Wisconsin, Board of Regents.